Pavlik wasn; even in the Top three for me...

Hardly anyone really rated pantera, he was a banger and nothing more. Now Taylor, sure he was the undisputed MW champ, but shit that guys reputation was getting worse by just about every fight since his last hopkins fight... The guy was showing by fight how clearly overrated he was and how ring lazy he was. He got knocked out of the top 10 p4p list before the fight, and was knocked out during it. It was a GREAT year for pavlik, but hardly a FOTY worthy imo, not by a long shot.

Mayweather beat an all time ring legend at his first shot and a new Weight. Oscar was not ring active sure, was he the best Oscar that had graced the ring? nop... but this guy doesn;t need to be fighitng 3 times a year now, he has faced so many greats, worked with so many great trainers there isn;t much more he can learn. Floyd impressed the hell out of me beating him. He then goes on to fight a top 10 p4p fighter, a Ring and undisputed champion at the weight below... The fact hatton was stepping up in weight had little baring on the outcome IMO... Floyd could of gone down and schooled him down there to. Didn't matter.