I wouldn't disagree with people who had Herman winning but a lot of those rounds were close and if Herman won it was close, not a robbery IMO. Although I always say the word robbery is thrown around too much and nobody agrees with me. I mean say you had it 7-5, that's one round from being a draw and there were a lot of close rounds, hows that a robbery?

I will say that Paulie has gotten a little overhyped/overrated. Edner Cherry and Lovemore N'dou are solid wins, they aren't great wins. And yes he had some moments against Cotto and he did show heart but he had to show heart cause he basically got the shit kicked out of him.

He's a good fighter but he's got a ways to go and for a guy that moves a lot and has good reflexes his defense can be a bit sketchy at times.