Probably Lacy vs Calzaghe. I'm not embarrassed that I picked Jeff Lacy, because back then Lacy was destroying everyone and seemed to be the "next big thing", and Calzaghe was looked at as a brittle handed guy who, although he had great skills, never really fought anyone of note and was probably past his prime.

But of course Lacy didn't win a fucking round so in hindsight yeah it was a pretty bad pick.