It's absurd to even compare oscar to Roy. Meaning don't insult roy by comparing and obvious lesser fighter/boxer to him..

Forget all the speculative crap as to whose resume was better..it's a fact that roy beat more fighters that were champions or major title holders at some point in their career let see of the top

james toney
Bernard hopkins
anotinio tarver
montell griffin
clinton woods
john ruiz
eric lucas
julio caesar gonzales
glen kelly
felix trinidad
reggie johnson
otis grant
lou de valle
virgil hill
mike mccallum
vinnny pazeniza

well that's 16 guys who were champs at some point during their career, which is more than can be said for the opponents of some of these other so-called ATGs...

not to mention guys like Thulani maligna, merqui sosa, bryant brannon, the aforementioned virgil hill, and thomas tate these fighters who gave the "fighter's roy didn't face" hell by going the distance only to be stopped by roy....