Booze,I agree with your analysis,he's fought some top fighters but I think he has a dam boring style. And my main criticism of him is not his resume but these poins:

1.)after every loss,his fans cry robbery as does he.Name me one robbery of his.All his losses have been close fights.

2.)his ranting and raving about not wanting to fight guys like AA,Kess,turning down a career high payday v JT in a rematch and then continuing ranting and raving.

3.) He thinks he's some sort of draw.

I have no doubt he is a tough fighter, skilled but I don't find his style enjoyable and he's nowhere near the draw he think he is.