Dam I've seen some weird things...Hatton top 10?Not on the run he's been on since the Tszyu fight.

Few mentions of Calderon who should be in there on the basis of his win over Cazarez who must have outhweighed him by 20 plus pounds,and it was Ivan's first fight at the weight.That would have been like Mayweather fighting Margarito or Williams in his first fight at WW(exactly). Not to mention his COUNTLESS defences.

Chris John.....

Juan Diaz.... Wins over Freitas and Julio Diaz don't make you P4P. Cotto had to beat Judah,Mosley,and 3 unbeaten future world champs(Torres,Paulie and QUintana) to get into P4P lists. Diaz is nowhere near that.

Probably the best lists I've seen:Mikes although I'd take out Winky and put CAlderon and take out with Pavlik joint 10th or something: