Quote Originally Posted by Pacstraightleft View Post
Quote Originally Posted by Pavlik View Post
Pac greatly deserves his number 2 spot beating MAB, EM convincingly and JMM in a hairline. But P4P number1 hell no!!!
All I can say is for a former 107 pounder to achieve all of these is already a great feat IMO and warrants great RESPECT.
Did Manny deserves this victory, YES. In fact he should've gotten the nod 4 years ago in the first place if it wasn't for Judge Bert Clements.
Marquez wasnt battered but Manny did edge him a lil in this fight and a win is win.
I agree with you. But if Pac wins against David Diaz and capture his belt, not only Pac will be a 4-time world time (4 diff divisions),... but also a #1 p4p king!
I disagree strongly with this, David Diaz is a marginal champion in a currently unimpressive weight class, how would beating him be enough to move Pac to the P4P #1 spot? IMO beating Marquez, who is/was top 5 P4P on almost everyones list, is much more impressive that beating Diaz, even if Diaz fights at a higher weight. I could understand Pac being anywhere from about 2-4 on the P4P list, maybe as low as 5 if you believe Marquez should've won the fight but there is no way he surpassed PBF by beating Diaz.