Roy beat Tarver after losing 30 lbs in a month or two. And if he wasn't affected by the weight-loss, he would have beat him badly. Even in the second fight, Jones was doing great, and controlling the action, landing at will. It's just too bad he got caught with one. After getting KOd by Johnson, Roy is gun-shy. Otherwise, he would have beat Tarver the third fight.

Tarver is good, but nowhere near Jones.