I'm not really going to get involved here.
I'm just going to state what I've stated in every thread on this fight.

Hopkins did A GOOD JOB.
He employed dirty tactics and questionable ethics, but he did a good job.
He neutralised Calzaghe's counterpunching, limited the effect of his speed and volume and also disgruntled Calzaghe slightly.
Hopkins, although not popularising himself with his performance made the most using his aged 43 year old body and gave the younger man hell in the early going. Hopkins' lack of restraint on his head and holding overshadowed some very intelligent footwork, some great defensive ideas and some great counters.

Boxing is a business. Fighters are there to make money, not impress us. Hopkins made his best attempt at amking the big money.

Calzaghe, once again demonstrated his resiliance, compusure and work ethic.

Give both ment their credit.

They're both world champions, they have the right to disrespect each other if they want.
But we can't dis either guy, they've got skills and expierience many of us will never be able to imagine.