Did Joe just take away the p4p throne from Manny?

[Unknowndonor]

Yes, i was already impressed with Cotto, but the win against Gomez didn't do anything for me.

[Althugz]

I've said it before and i'm sticking to it. Respect to Joe but he has left it too late in his career to ever be considered P4P number 1 in my opinion. He would need too many more fights against big names to get there and his shelf life isn't going to allow for that.
JLAQ, don't make me laugh comparing Calzaghe's resume to that of Manny Pacquaio, Mayweather and even a whole host of others. These guys have been fighting live world champions at the peaks of their career's where as Joe only started to do that age 33-34. He's doing well at this advanced age but it's too late for me to consider him even in the top 3.

[Tito BHB]

You know what.. This has bugging me FOREVER!!

FUCK THIS BULLSHIT!

Im with HIM man!.. Number one is old yo.. Fuck number one and its father..

Im talking number two yo!

Yeah man number two is hereby the big time and he who is number two holds the crown man! Yeah joe c P4P Number 2 for life!

Pfft..

Joe just has to do something like.. Beat 3 legends and be extremely exciting..Then he will steal manny's coveted number two crown