Joe Calzaghe now no. 3 in Ring Mag's latest P4P rankings

[amat]

I would put him at 4 but to be honest, I've really soured on these P4P deals, do not like them much at all anymore. It seems like splitting hairs and pointless to compare fighters from different weight divisions and the lack of criteria really turned me off these.

[bcollins]

I would put him at 4 but to be honest, I've really soured on these P4P deals, do not like them much at all anymore. It seems like splitting hairs and pointless to compare fighters from different weight divisions and the lack of criteria really turned me off these.

I have the same problem with p4p lists - no clear criteria for determining the rankings. They mean completely diffrent things for different people.