Quote Originally Posted by Mr. Nightmare
TAYLOR - Would be able to say he beat Hopkins, Hopkins again, and then Winky. If B-Hop was #1 p4p for the first fight, and Taylor beat him twice, then he beats the current # 2 guy, it's hard to go against him.

WINKY - Would be able to say he beat Mosley, Mosley again, Trinidad, and Taylor. Those are 4 impressive wins. And he's currently # 2 p4p.

PBF - Yeah, he just beat Judah. But before that it was the washed up Sharmba Mitchell, the overrated Gatti, and the overmatched Bruseles. Not saying he aiint # 1, but the winner on June 17 has a good case, too.
I have absolutely no doubt that neither Winky or Taylor would be able to compete with Kessler so of course they could not be ranked no1 p4p. Kessler would outbox or stop both guys.