Call me crazy,but I miss James Toney in the HW division...

[Spicoli]

Toney is his own worst enemy.........Also White Castle burgers No question that he was a lightning rod that could stir it up with rowdy nature.Can not see him being a factor though.WHEN he was in peak form.....He was one of the best all around fighters there ever was.

Estrada & Eddie chambers just do not do it for me ....

[Master]

What if James Toney that beat Holyfield fought like that in each and every subsequent heavyweight fight? What would he have achieved by now?

[El Kabong]

OK.......you're crazy





I am just sad he never got to fight Wladimir, all those Toney fans were so confident that he would beat Wlad...not only did I want to see James Toney's defeat crush his fans but I wanted to hear Larry Merchant say those marvelous words again "That whale was just harpooned"

A Toney-Tyson fight would have been good had Tyson not lost to Williams or McBride

[Master]

If it was the Toney that beat Holyfield, I am shamed to say he would have beaten Tyson, if it was the Toney that fought Rahman and Peter..... he still would have beaten Tyson.

[SweetPea]

Toney's biggest mistake was that he spent too many years draining himself at 168/175, then he spent the end of his career as a fat overweight heavyweight.

If he had just stayed in the 180s/190s for most of his career, he could have been an all-time great cruiserweight.

I'm a big Toney fan but he needs to hang it up. He's toast.