You have to defeat top pound for pound fighters to be considered a top pound for pound fighter, and it seems like Oscar loses to everyone good these days, except those that are no where near top fighters like Vargas, Forbes, Mayorga. Oscar beats an over-matched Gatti, an old Chavez twice, gets a gift against Whitaker, gets smacked around by Sturm-why does this guy still make so much money? Too many casual fans who don't know a damn thing about boxing.