Quote Originally Posted by AC-Cobra
The fact of the matter is, Baldomir is the CHAMP agt welterweight, he beat the recognised champ and is therfore himself the champ. I personally wouldnt of cared if Floyd fought Judah, I dont believe after his displays he desrved to fight for the title again or fight Floyd. However I can see how the boxing public would demand it.

My very simple point. In any situation where you have a clear champion, which Zab was before the Baldomir, the person that beats him is obviously then the champ. No matter what you, the media or anyone thinks, surely Floyd then cant go around claiming to be the champ without actually having beaten THE CHAMP. There is no doubt in my mind that Floyd SHOULD beat Baldomir, but that doesnt stop the fact that he has to be beat him to justify his boasts of being the best and the champion.


(I noticed I used the word champ a lot, sorry if it reads badly beacuse of it)
I actually agree with you...beat the champs..forget about the contenders...beat the guy who has the belts..i had a thread where i said that pbf should have fought baldocosby because he was obviously better than judah..people said i must be crazy...

so if you can honestly say you wouldn't criticize pbf had he not fought judah then cool...