Battle of the Middle/Super middleweights

[Spicoli]

I think the idea of Pavlik beating Hearns, or Calzaghe beating Toney, if we are talking PRIME fighters here, is ludicrous. Hearns would KTFO Pavlik about 9 out of 10 times imo, Pavlik would have a punchers chance nothing more, he couldn't box with Thommy and Hearns could easily KO him with one punch. Anythone who think any Joe Calzaghe that has ever lived could beat the Toney that fought Barkley, is simply saying so because they are from the UK. I see NO possible way Calzaghe could beat Toney, just no freaking way. He couldn't dream of as much as bothering James with his power, and his style would allow James to land those sneaky right counters all day.

Have to agree here,Hearns had far too many tools in the arsenal for oncoming Pavlik who at times has a leaky defense,And yes Hearns chin would be in jeporday But Pavlik is not exactley Will o' The wisp him self.

A tip top Toney and Calzaghe would be great.Calzaghe could exploit Toneys habit of "timing" out some rounds.....Constant pressure but I just see Toneys vast array of Punches picking holes in Calzaghe over 12 or less.That short Inside Right off the shoulder roll Of Toney would cause Joe fits.