Would Kelly Pavlik end Calzaghe's undefeated record if they met?

[JT Rock]

I would have to see a bit more of Pavlik before I can make a desicion like this... He beat Miranda, and JT 2x which most didnt regard him all that high at the end. Kelly personifies all that is good about boxing.(power,chin,personality, excitement, outstanding sportsman)

JC as we know has proven himself to all the critics, especially me FORMALLY one of his biggest. 2nd best supermiddle of all time undefeated and over 10 year reigning champion along with being Lineal and universally recognized Champion of 2 divisions... His plaque and space have already been set aside in Canastota.... Enough said

If Kelly beats him its only because Joe got old and less mobile... But Kelly's Helacious right is his meal ticket and Joe's achilles heal. The question is can Calzaghe keep showing angles so Kelly cant set and sit on his punches.

[Gandalf]

I think Calzaghe: Pavlik is a great matchup. I think Calzaghe, if he can find that Kessler form one more time, can beat Pavlik by a clear UD. But Pavlik will always make it interesting with his workrate and huge right hand.

Nothing not to like in this possible matchup...

[CutMeMick]

I'm 50/50 on this one...

It's puncher meets the boxer....

Can the puncher land his money shot?
Can the boxer fight well for 12 full rounds?

I can't decide really...

[yvonne]

I'm 50/50 on this one...

It's puncher meets the boxer....

Can the puncher land his money shot?
Can the boxer fight well for 12 full rounds?

I can't decide really...

IM WITH YOU MATE.I LIKE BOTH FIGHTERS.I LIKE TO SEE THE FIGHT GET MADE!I AGREE IT'LL BE 50/50.IM A BETTING FREAK WHEN IT COMES TO THE NOBLE ART GAME,BUT IF THE FIGHT DOES GET PULLED OFF THEN IT WOULD BE REALLY HARD TO BET ON EITHER BOXER.IT WOULD BE A FANTASIC FIGHT THOUGH.....MOUTH WATERING

[southakron314]

If this fight went to the cards Pavlik's face will just look sweaty and Calzaghe's will look like ground beef. Hopkins looked like he was out for a jog. Calzaghe has nothing that hurts Pavlik. Nothing Calfagey can do will hurt Pavlik. Joe knows and will see what Pavlik can do to a opponet come the 7th when Lockett gets mauled in the ring. This Lockett fight will shock me if it goes more than 7 rounds. Im sure Calzaghe will be rings side for this dismantling of a human.I hope he sees it. I hope Pavlik knocks him out in extreme fashion. Like Taylor slump over almost lifeless in the corner. Or Miranda beaten so bad he looked like a new born kitten with both eyes shut. I hope I dont even need to mention what he did to Zertuche. I hope this fight happens around middle of 2009 when Pavlik is ready to move up. I hope its at a good catch wieght 170-172. I think how prone Joe looked agianst the right hands of Hopkins that Pavlik will connct with his own . Pavlik is a real busy fighter 80-120 punches a round. The right will land and it will hurt.

[GAME]

If Joe has the choice of a Jones or Pavlik fight he should go for Jones.

Even if he beats Pav people will just say he was unproven just like Kessler even though he was a unified world champ .

Pav can end Joes run but if I were putting money on it I'd have to go with Joe on points . He has the experience and boxing brain to outscore Kelly . Taylor came close last time but Joe works at a higher pace and I think he'd be too good for Kelly if they met now . Maybe in a years time things might change .

[gudnite vienna]

yeh 2 b honest taylor could of won that re-match.. it was that close in my eyes...

what makes everyone think that pavlik would KO calzaghe, in my eyes Pavlik is far from an elite fighter... whereas JC is proven..

It looks like JC is gona beat another sitting duck across the pond