Dawson Vs Calzaghe

[ICB]

You need to stop reading Boxing Rec and try actually watching fights. Johnson got robbed against Sheika. Only an idiot would say Sheika fukked him up. So it's no surprise you would say it

Agreed with VD here i see the fight and Johnson deserved to win the fight clearly IMO, but its nothing new you could make a case for majority of Johnson's close decision losses that they should of indeed went to Johnson.

What a surprise

Not sure what you mean by that comment, but Johnson clearly beat Sheika end of. Anyone body who watched the fight knows that, Preme obviously never see the fight.

[RozzySean]

Agreed with VD here i see the fight and Johnson deserved to win the fight clearly IMO, but its nothing new you could make a case for majority of Johnson's close decision losses that they should of indeed went to Johnson.

What a surprise

Not sure what you mean by that comment, but Johnson clearly beat Sheika end of. Anyone body who watched the fight knows that, Preme obviously never see the fight.

Preme vs VD - the biggest Calzaghe fanboy vs the biggest Calzaghe hater. ICB, there is no sense talking about Calzaghe with either of these guys

[HattonTheHammer]

Would be a one sided hiding to nothing if the 2 ever met and i suspect JC would get a heavy points win.

What possibly does chad dawson bring to the table that jeff lacy never??

[RozzySean]

Would be a one sided hiding to nothing if the 2 ever met and i suspect JC would get a heavy points win.

What possibly does chad dawson bring to the table that jeff lacy never??

Handspeed, defense, skill, reach. Dawson is a much better fighter than Lacy. Still, I would pick Joe 116-112.

[HattonTheHammer]

Would be a one sided hiding to nothing if the 2 ever met and i suspect JC would get a heavy points win.

What possibly does chad dawson bring to the table that jeff lacy never??

Handspeed, defense, skill, reach. Dawson is a much better fighter than Lacy. Still, I would pick Joe 116-112.

lacy is still a class act who has it within him to become a world champion at 168 if he ever manages to get over recouring injuries.

Ive rated dawson for a while but still think the guy is a long way off being the finished article.

Pavlik, kessler, miranda, RJJ, froch - all deserve a shot at JC before you can start mentioning CD`s name!!

[Violent Demise]

Would be a one sided hiding to nothing if the 2 ever met and i suspect JC would get a heavy points win.

What possibly does chad dawson bring to the table that jeff lacy never??

Handspeed, defense, skill, reach. Dawson is a much better fighter than Lacy. Still, I would pick Joe 116-112.

lacy is still a class act who has it within him to become a world champion at 168 if he ever manages to get over recouring injuries.

Ive rated dawson for a while but still think the guy is a long way off being the finished article.

Pavlik, kessler, miranda, RJJ, froch - all deserve a shot at JC before you can start mentioning CD`s name!!

Really? What have Pavlik, Miranda and Fraud ever done at 175 to deserve a shot at Calzaghe?

[ICB]

Would be a one sided hiding to nothing if the 2 ever met and i suspect JC would get a heavy points win.

What possibly does chad dawson bring to the table that jeff lacy never??

Oh come on comparing Lacy to Dawson is a bit silly bro IMO, Lacy kept walking forward against Calzaghe looking for 1 big punch all night, Dawson is taller, he has better skills, has a better defense, better foot work, better hand speed, the list just goes on and on.

[RozzySean]

Would be a one sided hiding to nothing if the 2 ever met and i suspect JC would get a heavy points win.

What possibly does chad dawson bring to the table that jeff lacy never??

Handspeed, defense, skill, reach. Dawson is a much better fighter than Lacy. Still, I would pick Joe 116-112.

lacy is still a class act who has it within him to become a world champion at 168 if he ever manages to get over recouring injuries.

Ive rated dawson for a while but still think the guy is a long way off being the finished article.

Pavlik, kessler, miranda, RJJ, froch - all deserve a shot at JC before you can start mentioning CD`s name!!

Froch? Are you serious? You can't be serious.

Kessler? Why would you rematch somebody your beat so clearly.

Miranda? That's even more silly than Froch.

Pavlik - maybe, but he still has fights to make at 160.

Jones - This will probably happen, but not because Jones deserves it.

Lacy may be a class act, but Peter Manfredo was outboxing him until Jeff caught him. In every respect except power, Dawson is a superior fighter. He schooled Adamek, he got the win over Glen Johnson, and he has a win on his resume over Eric Harding. Those three wins are better than anything Lacy has every done. He holds the WBC belt. If Calzaghe wanted to fight the most deserving challenger, it would be Dawson, but he won't do it because he has very little to gain. Even Tarver has more claim than the people you mention.

[HattonTheHammer]

Handspeed, defense, skill, reach. Dawson is a much better fighter than Lacy. Still, I would pick Joe 116-112.

lacy is still a class act who has it within him to become a world champion at 168 if he ever manages to get over recouring injuries.

Ive rated dawson for a while but still think the guy is a long way off being the finished article.

Pavlik, kessler, miranda, RJJ, froch - all deserve a shot at JC before you can start mentioning CD`s name!!

Really? What have Pavlik, Miranda and Fraud ever done at 175 to deserve a shot at Calzaghe?

Naturally im talking about a 168/catchweight fight.

pavlik/miranda wouldnt dream of stepping up to 175 for JC - froch could manage it and his desire to make the fight happen would be enough to make it a light heavyweight contest.

Of course the chances of any of these fights going down are non existent.

All ifs and buts - JC will fight either RJJ for another big name on his CV or will solidify himself as the number1 at 168+ against pavlik!!

[Violent Demise]

lacy is still a class act who has it within him to become a world champion at 168 if he ever manages to get over recouring injuries.

Ive rated dawson for a while but still think the guy is a long way off being the finished article.

Pavlik, kessler, miranda, RJJ, froch - all deserve a shot at JC before you can start mentioning CD`s name!!

Really? What have Pavlik, Miranda and Fraud ever done at 175 to deserve a shot at Calzaghe?

Naturally im talking about a 168/catchweight fight.

pavlik/miranda wouldnt dream of stepping up to 175 for JC - froch could manage it and his desire to make the fight happen would be enough to make it a light heavyweight contest.

Of course the chances of any of these fights going down are non existent.

All ifs and buts - JC will fight either RJJ for another big name on his CV or will solidify himself as the number1 at 168+ against pavlik!!

But the thread title says Dawson-Calzaghe. Which is the 175 division. Dawson is worthy of fighting Calzaghe