So what is now your revised p4p top 10???

[Macho]

To me this is the real one right now :

1- Manny Pacquiao
2- Miguel Cotto
3- Kelly Pavlik
4- Joe Calzague
5- Israel Vasquez
6- Rafael Marquez
7- Winky Wright
8- Ivan Calderon
9- JMM
10- Ricky Hatton

If Pacquiao win his next fight against Diaz , he could still in the first place
If Cotto win his next fight against Margaro , he could still in the second place and both positions depend of their performance in the fight......

[donnydarkoIRL]

1.Manny Pacquiao
2.Joe Calzaghe
3.Miguel Cotto
4.Kristian Mijares
5.Israel Vasquez
6.Kelly Pavlik
7.Juan Manuel Marquez
8.Antonio Margarito
9.Joel Casamayor
10.Rafeal Marquez

[Fenster]

I think Marquez beat Pac TWICE. And he beat John.

Wherever Pac is Marquez should be near him. In my case.. he must be ranked in front.

[HattonTheHammer]

I think Marquez beat Pac TWICE. And he beat John.

Wherever Pac is Marquez should be near him. In my case.. he must be ranked in front.

In an ideal world yes

But you put a guy over a man he has just been beaten by twice over and naturally people start asking questions.

Vegas judges are now pretty set on awarding fights to the busier fighters, i cant remember the last time a judge awarded a close decision on the guy with the better accuracy.

[Kel]

I think Marquez beat Pac TWICE. And he beat John.

Wherever Pac is Marquez should be near him. In my case.. he must be ranked in front.

Yeah but he had some points deducted in the John fight which obviously went againsed him in the judges eyes (also depends how the judges are scoring the round with the foul). The second Pac fight I have only seen once, live, but I never grumbled at the decision it was a close one. Should watch that again actually.

[Fenster]

I have no problem with Pac getting the decision over Marquez - twice. They were both very very close fights.

But in my book Marquez won both. Therefore Marquez is the better fighter.

So in the world of nonsense mythical P4P lists.. I think Marquez quite rightly deserves a place above Pac (if like me you believe him the superior fighter)

[hitmanhatton]

To me this is the real one right now :

1- Manny Pacquiao
2- Miguel Cotto
3- Kelly Pavlik
4- Joe Calzague
5- Israel Vasquez
6- Rafael Marquez
7- Winky Wright
8- Ivan Calderon
9- JMM
10- Ricky Hatton

If Pacquiao win his next fight against Diaz , he could still in the first place
If Cotto win his next fight against Margaro , he could still in the second place and both positions depend of their performance in the fight......

Thats a good list Macho imo

the only thing id change is maybe to swap winky wit JMM simply due to his inactivity of late , a win against a big name opponent in the near future could see him back in the mix