So what is now your revised p4p top 10???

[Beanflicker]

Not sure about a top 10 but my top 3 are Pacquiao, Calzaghe and Cotto

[totalboxing1]

Whats people's reasoning for having Hopkins in their top 10. Surely his status there is reflective of his record and big names on it?

If its ability, taking away weight how is it justified that Pavlik goes in there. He does just the job without any exceptional skill, and his age means he doesn't have such an accomplished list of victims.

Its always difficult to weigh up people to put into a Pound-For-Pound list.

For me Hopkins wouldn't be on there, because he is abit diminished and although he has fought alot of big names, i still dont think he should be in there.

Pavlik should be, despite his lack of many great names on his record, or his technique. He still gets the job done and has a great punch.

Could there ever be a justified points system that could be created to decide a top 10 pound for pound list? I think not

[SE7EN]

Whats people's reasoning for having Hopkins in their top 10. Surely his status there is reflective of his record and big names on it?

If its ability, taking away weight how is it justified that Pavlik goes in there. He does just the job without any exceptional skill, and his age means he doesn't have such an accomplished list of victims.

Its always difficult to weigh up people to put into a Pound-For-Pound list.

For me Hopkins wouldn't be on there, because he is abit diminished and although he has fought alot of big names, i still dont think he should be in there.

Pavlik should be, despite his lack of many great names on his record, or his technique. He still gets the job done and has a great punch.

Could there ever be a justified points system that could be created to decide a top 10 pound for pound list? I think not

I think the reason Hopkins is still on the list because #3 Calzaghe had a questionable win against him. Just like Pacquiao's win against Marquez.

[C-Lo]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Miguel Cotto
4. Joe Calzaghe
5. Israel Vasquez
6. Kelly Pavlik
7. Rafael Marquez
8. Bernard Hopkins
9. Cristian Mijares
10. Joel Casamayor

[C-Lo]

Anyone else finding it weird looking at all these P4P lists and not seeing Mayweather's name on it?

[:::PSL:::]

Anyone else finding it weird looking at all these P4P lists and not seeing Mayweather's name on it?

It is weird.

[CFH]

These lists are so subjective, but I'll give it a shot.

1. Pacquiao
2. J.M. Marquez
3. Vazquez
4. Calzaghe
5. Cotto
6. Hopkins
7. Rafa Marquez
8. Mijares
9. Pavlik
10. Guzman (based on skills, he'd be higher if he'd fought better competition)