Aright I rented this game, I will say this the controls are definately not as good as fight night much less intuitive and more Mortal Kombat like.
The phantom punch thing is very frustrating.

The career mode is much better than fight night though, the story is like watching a documentary which is very cool. There are a lot of current great fighters.

All in all I actually liked it better than most of the reviewers I read about online, but probably not as much as CountryBoy. I probably will buy it though as I'm getting tired of destroying the computer on FNR3. One of these days I'll get Xbox Live.