If Calzaghe defeated RJJ + Pavlik there can be no doubters!!

[uwey]

There is always doubt. Boxing judging is not an exact science. I thought b hopkins pull out a W against Joe C. What if JC wins close split D's over Roy and Ghost do U think there will be no doubt. Boxing judging, if U like it or not is basicaly about opinion, Politics and the next big thing. If U dont believe me just watch Larry Holmes vs. Mike Spinx second fight. Powers didnt want Holmes any more. Leonard vs Hagler. B Hops wasnt wanted no more by the powers that be. Fight could have went either way but I knew Taylor would get the decision. Look at the whole picture and understand that politics is the underlining factor in Razor Sharp Decisions.

[Thread Stealer]

Beating Pavlik would help his all-time standing, but I don't know about Roy at this stage in his career.

[Phil]

oh but there will still be doubters, say if Froch was to beat Taylor then Calzaghe will get shit for not fighting him.