I like Joe alot but at his age father time has to come knocking soon and against a RJJ that has the handspeed and power advantage along with having had to deal with adversity(Johnson&Tarver) so I would give him the slight edge in experience... People point to Jones as shot but fact of the matter is Roy has adopted a very effective style with less leaping in and a tighter defense thats not predicated so much on Reflex as it is basic fundamental boxing. Its not fair to compare a prime Jones to his current self, in his prime no one could touch him, but this version aint to shabby either. I would rate an 08 version of Jones better than anyone that Calzaghe has faced in relation to the speed and power..