UK Boxing Experts?

[Deanrw]

Barry McGuigan reckons Hatton should fight Cotto because he'd beat him

What does it take to be an expert? I'm pretty sure he called Edwin Valero a top ten p4p'er as well a few weeks ago.

Then take into account sky's dreadful p4p lists.

Seriosuly, i think Steve Bunce is the saviour.

Guys with this amount of knowledge shouldn't be allowed anywhere near the telly

I made a post about this subject a long time ago. IMO there is no such thing as a boxing expert. There are too many flaws and emotions involved with the human brain and boxing is an inexact science.

Unless there is a huge disparity with the fighters involved, it usually comes down to a roll of the dice and still, upsets do happen.

Bunce predicted Lockett would beat Pavlik which had huge emotion involved. Atlas's predictions are way less than 50%, which is really bad because doing an "ini mini miney moe" would guarantee him a 50% result!LOL

[GAME]

I dont like Bunce. He has no class and makes the show look cheap .

[Gandalf]

I dont like Bunce. He has no class and makes the show look cheap .

Bunce just seems so thick to me. Not very articulate and the manner in which he carries himself just causes me to shake my head. They are all pretty lame.

[Kirkland Laing]

I don't think Bunce thought Lockett was going to beat Pavlik, he just had to say it to make people interested in the fight. He's probably the best boxing writer in Britain but not so impressive on TV. He may get better in a year or so.

[GAME]

I dont like Bunce. He has no class and makes the show look cheap .

Bunce just seems so thick to me. Not very articulate and the manner in which he carries himself just causes me to shake my head. They are all pretty lame.

Yeah its like listening to a drunk in a pub talking about boxing , but Bunce is on tv so he should be presenting an experts analysis. He's just a fan who likes boxing but his opinion is no better than anyones else. Its not as if he were a boxer himself. What does he know?

I prefer guys who have been there and done that who can present their insight in a professional way . Not a scummy loudmouth !

[Kirkland Laing]

I dont like Bunce. He has no class and makes the show look cheap .

Bunce just seems so thick to me. Not very articulate and the manner in which he carries himself just causes me to shake my head. They are all pretty lame.

Yeah its like listening to a drunk in a pub talking about boxing , but Bunce is on tv so he should be presenting an experts analysis. He's just a fan who likes boxing but his opinion is no better than anyones else. Its not as if he were a boxer himself. What does he know?

I prefer guys who have been there and done that who can present their insight in a professional way . Not a scummy loudmouth !

He used to be an amateur boxer. He still goes to most amateur events too. There's probably nobody in the country as knowledgeable about the British boxing scene as Bunce which you can tell when you read his stuff. He's different altogether on TV. More rubbish.

[Master]

Antony Small said something even worse, on Setanta he said that Margarito should fight Hatton. He really must like snuff movies or Antony has taken too many punches to the head. WTF!!!