Does an knock-down automatically win you the round...???

[JohnnyKickAss]

I thought they called it the 10 point must system because barring a penalty one fighter must be given 10 points. That was just my understanding of the rules.

Damn...I've forgotten this...but you are right...this would actually mean that a knock-down wins you the rnd even if its the only punch that connected from one boxer while the other one has beaten the crap out of him...

[killersheep]

I thought they called it the 10 point must system because barring a penalty one fighter must be given 10 points. That was just my understanding of the rules.

Damn...I've forgotten this...but you are right...this would actually mean that a knock-down wins you the rnd even if its the only punch that connected from one boxer while the other one has beaten the crap out of him...

That's based on my understanding I may very well be wrong. There was a fight on ESPN2 recently where one guy dominated the whole fight complete shutout, but at the final bell he got knocked down, he was definately winning the round by a mile until that happened, but I gave his opponent the round 10-8 as did the judges.

[JohnnyKickAss]

I thought they called it the 10 point must system because barring a penalty one fighter must be given 10 points. That was just my understanding of the rules.

Damn...I've forgotten this...but you are right...this would actually mean that a knock-down wins you the rnd even if its the only punch that connected from one boxer while the other one has beaten the crap out of him...

That's based on my understanding I may very well be wrong. There was a fight on ESPN2 recently where one guy dominated the whole fight complete shutout, but at the final bell he got knocked down, he was definately winning the round by a mile until that happened, but I gave his opponent the round 10-8 as did the judges.

Well...the 10 point must system doesn't work if both boxer get a point deducted in the same rnd...

[boxer1234]

This is whats wrong with the 10 point must system.

If a fighter is getting beaten badly for 2 minutes 59 seconds of the round but then lands a flash knockdown he wins the round.
The knockdown could be a graze of a glove to the canvas, or even achieved by the fighter being more off-balance than anything but nevertheless its stilll worth 2 points.

It can be complicated but it shouldn't be so black and white, when considering the points from a KD it should be really worth noting whether they deserved the 2 points. Such variables should include:

Was the fighter really hurt from the KD?
Was it more of an issue of the fighter being off-balance?
Was it just a scrape of the glove that touched the canvas?

[XaduBoxer]

I think yes coz even if you've been dominated by the other guy then you scored a KD, that round will be given to you as 10-9 as oppose to the normal KD score of 10-8. Definitely you win rounds with knockdownds.

[killersheep]

Damn...I've forgotten this...but you are right...this would actually mean that a knock-down wins you the rnd even if its the only punch that connected from one boxer while the other one has beaten the crap out of him...

That's based on my understanding I may very well be wrong. There was a fight on ESPN2 recently where one guy dominated the whole fight complete shutout, but at the final bell he got knocked down, he was definately winning the round by a mile until that happened, but I gave his opponent the round 10-8 as did the judges.

Well...the 10 point must system doesn't work if both boxer get a point deducted in the same rnd...

Penalties are the exception. If there are no penalties then the winner of the round must have 10 points.

[JohnnyKickAss]

That's based on my understanding I may very well be wrong. There was a fight on ESPN2 recently where one guy dominated the whole fight complete shutout, but at the final bell he got knocked down, he was definately winning the round by a mile until that happened, but I gave his opponent the round 10-8 as did the judges.

Well...the 10 point must system doesn't work if both boxer get a point deducted in the same rnd...

Penalties are the exception. If there are no penalties then the winner of the round must have 10 points.

Ahhh...okay...

[Andre]

Well...the 10 point must system doesn't work if both boxer get a point deducted in the same rnd...

Penalties are the exception. If there are no penalties then the winner of the round must have 10 points.

Ahhh...okay...

So a dead even round is 10 /10

must B

[Master]

I would score it 10-9 in favour of the fighter who scored the knock down but got the crap kicked out of him.

[Fenster]

That's based on my understanding I may very well be wrong. There was a fight on ESPN2 recently where one guy dominated the whole fight complete shutout, but at the final bell he got knocked down, he was definately winning the round by a mile until that happened, but I gave his opponent the round 10-8 as did the judges.

Well...the 10 point must system doesn't work if both boxer get a point deducted in the same rnd...

Penalties are the exception. If there are no penalties then the winner of the round must have 10 points.

That reminds me, it was never resolved whether or not judges always mark the round with a 10 (as in the 10 point must system) with the point deduction (when they happen) taken after the fight


Cutmemick, what happened to your ex-judge friend?