Hopkins vs Hagler?

[SimonH]

Depends:

Hopkins the brawler beats Hagler the brawler

Hopkins the brawler loses to Hagler the boxer

Hopkins the boxer loses to Hagler the boxer

Hopkins the boxer beats Hagler the brawler

I worked this out on:

Hopkins the boxer peaked in 1999 though 2001
Hopkins the brawler peaked in 1997/98

Hagler the boxer peaked 1977 though to 1979
Hagler the brawler peaked 1981 though to 1983

Exactly, it depends. Because Hagler and Hopkins are rare fighters who experienced two completely different primes So which one?

The Hagler who fought in the late 70s (77-79), beats any version of Hopkins; I actually have changed my opinion; I used to think the Hopkins who beat Trinidad would beat any version of Hagler, but I have rewatched some Hagler bouts from the 70s recently, and have changed my opinion.