I've heard all of the same things as the original poster about Reid. He should be pretty good to have actually beaten Calzaghe. I never used to like Lacy but after his hard fought battles with Omar Sheika and Vanderpool I respect him and like him. He is tough. I am going to go with Lacy, he is similiar to a 168 lb Tyson but minus the mental problems. Lacy by KO.