Juan Manuel Marquez vs Nate Campbell Anyone ?

[Kev]

I think Breidis Prescott deserves to be top 10 considering Amir Khan was about 8th in the Lightweight rankings according to Ring Magazine if i remember rightly and the way in which Breidis Prescott won also warrants a top 10 place i think Michael Katsidis should be out of the top 10 because of his back to back losses.

For what it's worth the Ring has Breidas Prescott in their rankings too at number 10.

Yea thats exactly where i have him i have no problem with him being at 9 or 10 and i think Michael Katsidis has been getting overrated ranking wise just because he fought bravely against Juan Diaz, Joel Casamayor, doesn't mean he should be rated higher because a loss is a loss unless were talking about something like Marquez vs Pacquiao 2 but it wasn't like that and to be honest Michael Katsidis's best win is against a guy who Amir Khan blew away in 1 round.

I agree Kats didn't really get any further than Khan did. The only name on his record is Graham Earl. Aside from that he fought complete nobodies.

As soon as he stepped up to world class he got knocked out by Casa and then dominated by Juan Diaz.

He has a better chin than Khan for sure, but in every other way he's inferior, even his power is grossly overratted.