I am saying this whole idea is wrong, Marquez hasn't done enough to be #1, he didn't win the second fight against Pacquaio, he deserves the #2 or #3 spot.

Calzaghe regardless of whether he beat Hopkins or not fought a really clsoe fight with Hopkins and beat Kessler, he should be in the top 5 no doubt. WTF is Mijares doing int he top 10 p4p yet? Especially at #5 thats very wrong, and don't even get me started on where you placed Pacquaio, if Marquez did beat in eitehr of those fights which he didn't, it would be by a point at most? That means Pacquaio should be in the top 3 by your logic.