Who wouldn't also do this??

[Salty]

How can he be a pedophile for fucking a 17 year old girl?

That's perfectly legal and acceptable here in the uk, in fact a couple years ago our government cheerily lowered the age for female buggery to 16 to avoid discriminating against those girls and their pervy older partners who wanted to experiment in some anal penetration but who under our previous antiquated laws had to wait until she turned 21.

Sounds like the dad was a nutter to me, caught his daughter having sex with a man and killed him, I mean if his daughter is 17 she can do what she wants.

You can't kill a guy over that. Of course its murder.

I think this line beats your argument into submission... "A convicted sex offender died "

Who wouldn't have done the same thing in that situation? I know I sure as hell would have. If he gets convicted it is a sad sad day.

Edit: the guy was also 52, not her high school sweet heart.