Look Oscar started his career at SFW lets not for get that guys. I hate pound for pound because it is not real thing it is just a guess. But if i took the Oscar from SFW or LW i pick him to beat Hopkins if they were the same weight i guess you could say. Trindad started 17 pounds over what Oscar started at and Hopkins was 30 pounds over were Oscar started at. To me pound for pound Oscar was better then both were. Like saying if Vitial beat Roy would that make him a better fighter then Roy i think not it just mean that he was bigger and had to much power for him to last with you get what i am saying i used kinda a weird example but all i got right but it does not matter the answer because anything you say could be right or wrong because in the end it is just a guess really and there is no way that we can prove it to be right or to be wrong.