Actually I think they are both overratted.

I don't expect Amir to win a world title any time soon if at all, unless it's the WBU title.

He has talent for sure but his defense is terrible, he wastes far too much energy leaping and jumping around the ring and he can't punch.

He's exciting to watch but as soon as he gets in with a fighter who can fight and punch he's going to get stopped.

His first real test will come when he faces Kevin Mitchell some time next year. I think he will get stopped to be honest.