If Calzaghe's record is so bad, whose is better?

[JT Rock]

Also Jones has every right to be able to challenge Calzaghe and have a match. It is far from a onesided affair and it will make money

[HattonTheHammer]

RJJ didnt actually look all that bad against trinidad and at times you got the old roy doing what he did best.

The problem he`ll come up against this time around which ultimately will be the deciding factor is he wont get the time nor space someone like tito moving up to 175 gave him and for RJJ to have a chance he really would have to produce arguably the performance of his career which im pretty sure he no longer has in him.

You cant blame calzaghe for taking this fight over dawson/tarver/froch etc, the man is 37 and for a guy considered an all time p4p great hasnt exactly made the kind of money the likes of RJJ and hopkins have.

If this is the inevitable calzaghe swangsong then he would of retired having just beat arguably the 2 best p4p boxers of the last decade and yet people will still have issues with his decision not to fight a younger hungrier boxer.

you just cannot win in these situations!!