If Calzaghe's record is so bad, whose is better?

**hfahrenheit** · 10-29-2008 03:03 PM

[quote=leftylee;623837][quote=Bilbo;623835]

Originally Posted by leftylee

...No shame in losing to Margarito.

No shame, yes, but definitely humbled in the way he lost- he gave Margarito everything he had and was brutally stopped.

**leftylee** · 10-29-2008 03:52 PM

[quote=hfahrenheit;624576][quote=leftylee;623837]

Originally Posted by Bilbo

No shame, yes, but definitely humbled in the way he lost- he gave Margarito everything he had and was brutally stopped.

You make it seem he was totally out of his depth. He completely dominated the first half of the fight.

And if your going by Cotto's facial injuries by any chance to believe he was "Brutally stopped" does that mean Paul Malignaggi was brutally beaten because did you see his face after Cotto ?

It was hardly brutal.

**Rantcatrat** · 10-29-2008 04:00 PM

[quote=leftylee;624627][quote=hfahrenheit;624576]

Originally Posted by leftylee

You make it seem he was totally out of his depth. He completely dominated the first half of the fight.

And if your going by Cotto's facial injuries by any chance to believe he was "Brutally stopped" does that mean Paul Malignaggi was brutally beaten because did you see his face after Cotto ?

It was hardly brutal.

Personally, I'd be going by the fact he was willed into submission. Cotto took three knees. I think, may be wrong, but he even told his corner he didn't want to fight any longer. Paulie lasted the whole twelve rounds and judges had him winning a handful too. Of course, he was solidly dominated by Cotto.