Quote Originally Posted by CFH View Post
I guess it depends what you value, overall skill or longevity. I'd say RJJ based on skill alone, but Calzaghe's reign has certainly been much more impressive than Jones'.
This is exactly right.

Calzaghe's best win at 168 IMO was over Kessler

Jones Jr's best win at 168 IMO was over Toney

I think ultimately you can make a very good case for both, however the longevity of Calzaghe's reign clinches it for me, although prime vs. prime I think Jones would have won. It's hard to believe that RJJ vs. JFAT was almost a decade and a half ago.