Vic Darchiniyan =#1 p4p

[eagle]

Well first I do not remember saying or could you show me anywhere did I ever say "Majares was not that good anyway"....

Second a puncher like Vic always has a chance...Hell Tyson had a "Chance" against Lewis but did anyone who knows anything really think he would win from punching power alone?

I just do not think that the win over Majares puts him in the P4P list...

I remember a thread not long ago where we spoke of the P4P list and I stated clearly that I do not think that just because a fighter holds 1 win over a P4P fighter that they deserve to be put on the P4P list..

There is a difference...

I also still believe that Doniare over all is a better fighter then Vic....

Lets put it this way...Darchinyan other then a mention here or there has not pushed for a rematch with Doniare...and Doniare has stated several times he would sign in a second...

Vic chose to move on on weight...so what does that tell you?

I think i may have not said what i meant to. I wasnt accusing u of being one of the guys that said Mijares wasnt good, i was mainly saying that i feel ure wrong to say that a Donaire Vic rematch would just go the same way. Yes Donaire Ko'd Vic, but what has he done since to prove that he has improved and that the KO of Vic wasnt maybe a bit lucky? I mean he landed the perfect shot that night, but he hasnt beaten another top guy to prove he can do it consistently. Not to say he wont.

Maldonado and Mthalane are nowhere near the opponents Vic has been fighting and beating. They arent in the same league as Gorres, Mijares and Kirilov.

Dont be offended by what i say, i agree with a lot of what u said. Vic dont really stand a chance against the top guys at superbantam. He relies on his power and at 122 he'd be outgunned.

To say Vic went up a division cos he was scared is a bit rough. Gorres In the Phillipines, Kirilov, and then Mijares are hardly the opponents of a guy who is scared. Now he is calling Donaire out. Vic did the right thing. Got beat, learned from it, got better, then when confidence is back calls out the guy who beat him. Nothing wrong with that.

I think Mthalane could give real problems to Gorres, Mijares, Kirilov and even Vic...
.

Really. How come?