Joe Calzaghe P4P #1?

[ICB]

Hopkins beating Pavlik worse tops this, and if you consider their fight really close then Hopkins has a "Draw" against Calzaghe, he beat Wright old or not is as good as KEssler IMO, Tarver, and now Pavlik. Maybe he should be ahead of Calzaghe .

J.k I still think Pacquaio has the better resume guys like Barrera and Morales weren't as washed up as Jones when Pacquaio tore them a new one, and he beat JMM who is a great fighter as well(who is still fighting great).

You don't think Morales was as washed up as Jones Jr?

So defeats to Zahir Raheem and David Diaz showed he was still at the top of his game right? Gimme a break Morales was done then. A couple years earlier whilst still past his best he got a win over Pacquio.

The first win over Barrera was sensational but the rematch was nothing more than a routine win over a aged fighter happy to go the distance.

Marquez is still very much in form, and he pushed Pacquaio to his limits.

No doubt Manny is p4p number 1 though his overal resume is superb, bit his recent performances in the last couple years havn't eclipsed Joe at all.

Calzaghe at super feather and lightweight would have won just the same

P4P JMM is all wrong for Joe Calzaghe.