Its no brainer of course Ricky Hatton did, despite all of Paul Malignaggi's injuries against Miguel Cotto. He was always in the fight and even stunned Miguel Cotto a few times, and he won atleast 4 rounds.

Except for the 1st round Paul Malignaggi lost every single round against Ricky Hatton. He was totally outclassed in every aspect and looked on the verge of quitting at the end.