Who beat Malignaggi better?

[HattonTheHammer]

Yes Cotto made a mess of Paulie's face but that doesn't mean he beat him better Cotto lost 4 or 5 rounds to Paulie going into the 11th and final round Hatton was 9 rounds to 1 up. And if it weren't for Paulie holding on for dear life when hurt Hatton could have perhaps stopped him.

Thats how I see it & thats why I voted Hatton ... because score card wise its Ricky hands down ... but as for making a mess of Paulie, then Cotto takes it....

So had ricky of busted paulie up in the 1st but then gone on to lose the next 11rounds and with it the fight by that logic you would still vote hatton.

Paulie was clearly unfazed by the broken jaw and dominated the proceeded rounds after it occoured

[Memphis]

They both beat him up good and proper, thats good enough for me, I dont care who did it the better.

[hfahrenheit]

Hatton: the stoppage, the amount of rounds won, and the fact that Paulie's clinching (read: hanging on for dear life) is what kept him on his feet.

[SigmaMu]

Yes Cotto made a mess of Paulie's face but that doesn't mean he beat him better Cotto lost 4 or 5 rounds to Paulie going into the 11th and final round Hatton was 9 rounds to 1 up. And if it weren't for Paulie holding on for dear life when hurt Hatton could have perhaps stopped him.

Thats how I see it & thats why I voted Hatton ... because score card wise its Ricky hands down ... but as for making a mess of Paulie, then Cotto takes it....

So had ricky of busted paulie up in the 1st but then gone on to lose the next 11rounds and with it the fight by that logic you would still vote hatton.

Paulie was clearly unfazed by the broken jaw and dominated the proceeded rounds after it occoured

The first 5 rounds went to Cotto but Cotto broke his hand mid 5th round. If Paulie could not get a round or two in against a one armed man then we have a problem. Paulie did a lot of holding against Cotto too. It was hit and then hug, wash, rinse and repeat. Cotto busted up Paulie worse but Hatton did better only because Hatton had all of his weapons. Paulie admits he is not the same fighter he was against Cotto that he was against Hatton. Paulie has fear and that fear came from Cotto and he was afraid it would happen again against Hatton and btw Cotto was also weight drained in his last fight at Jr Welter Weight just in case you forgot. I think Cotto could still move down to Jr Welter weight and put a beating on Hatton Considering it only took Floyd one punch to knock out Hatton, I think Cotto could knock Ricky out too