If Hatton beat Pacquiao is he P4P No1?

[ICB]

Pac is number 1 P4P. If Hatton beats Pac he becomes P4P #1. Simple logic.

I disagree totally Vernon Forrest beat Shane Mosley, who was P4P number 1 at that time. Infact he dominated the P4P number 1 fighter at that time, and he never come close to being P4P number 1.

And to my knowledge whenever a P4P number 1 fighter has been beat, the other fighter who beat them have never become P4P number 1. But i would put Ricky Hatton in the top 5 easily. And like Sonny just said by your logic if ODLH beat Manny Pacquiao, he would become P4P number 1 aswell ? do you see how flawed that logic is ?

[Preme]

I don't care if hatton beats him in the first round, he will not be the p4p #1 fighter. simple he isn't, never has been or never will be good enough to ever claim that title. He has never deserved to be in the top 5. and has hung on in the top 10 way to long.