It's all about the L-word (legacy)

[TitoFan]

Im sick of all this Oscar was the bigger man bullsh@t. He was not the bigger man and to his credit he made sure his weight was down. He was LIGHTER and WEAKER than Manny. He could have trained/eaten like he did for for the Mayweather fight and cut weight for the weigh in, then refueled to 160 on fight night, but he didnt. He would have probably done slightly better but he made the fight an even one on the weight issue. He was light throughout training camp. Oscar has a GREAT legacy.

Oh yeah... he purposely went into the ring lighter than Manny to make it a more even fight.



He miscalculated, plain and simple. He thought he could add Manny's scalp to his (cough) legacy, with Manny being the smaller man and all. But he miscalculated. He WAS weaker when he entered the ring. But not by design. Bottom line: He ran from the big boys at welter, only to get his *ss handed to him by the tiny Pacquiao. Life is good.

Him coming in the weight he did tells me that he respects Mannys speed and saw it as a possible threat. Yes he thought he would win but every fighter should going into a fight. But he didnt see it as an easy win. He wasnt weaker by design but he knew the risks of being weight drained and took a chance. He knew Manny weighed 147 in the ring in his last fight. Oscar has proven that he is not afraid of a chellenge. I thought this fight was a mismatch too in favor of Oscar, but he could have fought anyone and got criticism.

You manage to be wrong three times in one sentence. "Oscar's not afraid of a challenge?" If that were the case, he would have gone after Margarito, or another real welterweight, instead of thinking he had an easy payday against the much smaller Pacquiao. Oh... so you thought the fight was a mismatch in Oscar's favor, but Oscar himself saw it as a dangerous challenge. Don't buy it. Finally, he could have fought anybody and gotten criticism? Negative. Believe me when I tell you... and I'm as anti-Oscar as they come... I would've respected Oscar a lot more had he taken the fight that everyone in boxing wanted to see. Him against Margarito.

[Boom Boom]

Oh yeah... he purposely went into the ring lighter than Manny to make it a more even fight.



He miscalculated, plain and simple. He thought he could add Manny's scalp to his (cough) legacy, with Manny being the smaller man and all. But he miscalculated. He WAS weaker when he entered the ring. But not by design. Bottom line: He ran from the big boys at welter, only to get his *ss handed to him by the tiny Pacquiao. Life is good.

Him coming in the weight he did tells me that he respects Mannys speed and saw it as a possible threat. Yes he thought he would win but every fighter should going into a fight. But he didnt see it as an easy win. He wasnt weaker by design but he knew the risks of being weight drained and took a chance. He knew Manny weighed 147 in the ring in his last fight. Oscar has proven that he is not afraid of a chellenge. I thought this fight was a mismatch too in favor of Oscar, but he could have fought anyone and got criticism.

You manage to be wrong three times in one sentence. "Oscar's not afraid of a challenge?" If that were the case, he would have gone after Margarito, or another real welterweight, instead of thinking he had an easy payday against the much smaller Pacquiao. Oh... so you thought the fight was a mismatch in Oscar's favor, but Oscar himself saw it as a dangerous challenge. Don't buy it. Finally, he could have fought anybody and gotten criticism? Negative. Believe me when I tell you... and I'm as anti-Oscar as they come... I would've respected Oscar a lot more had he taken the fight that everyone in boxing wanted to see. Him against Margarito.

I would never have known..He fought the Bigger Hopkins, P4P King Floyd, Underfeated Tito, Shane, the list goes on, the man is not afraid of a challenge.

[CGM]

Him coming in the weight he did tells me that he respects Mannys speed and saw it as a possible threat. Yes he thought he would win but every fighter should going into a fight. But he didnt see it as an easy win. He wasnt weaker by design but he knew the risks of being weight drained and took a chance. He knew Manny weighed 147 in the ring in his last fight. Oscar has proven that he is not afraid of a chellenge. I thought this fight was a mismatch too in favor of Oscar, but he could have fought anyone and got criticism.

You manage to be wrong three times in one sentence. "Oscar's not afraid of a challenge?" If that were the case, he would have gone after Margarito, or another real welterweight, instead of thinking he had an easy payday against the much smaller Pacquiao. Oh... so you thought the fight was a mismatch in Oscar's favor, but Oscar himself saw it as a dangerous challenge. Don't buy it. Finally, he could have fought anybody and gotten criticism? Negative. Believe me when I tell you... and I'm as anti-Oscar as they come... I would've respected Oscar a lot more had he taken the fight that everyone in boxing wanted to see. Him against Margarito.

I would never have known..He fought the Bigger Hopkins, P4P King Floyd, Underfeated Tito, Shane, the list goes on, the man is not afraid of a challenge.

So true, Boom Boom. reps.

p.s. Dahlberg is a smart ass, always has been. He probably sits back and reads his own articles over and over and says to himself, "boy am I clever!".

[antimoron]

You manage to be wrong three times in one sentence. "Oscar's not afraid of a challenge?" If that were the case, he would have gone after Margarito, or another real welterweight, instead of thinking he had an easy payday against the much smaller Pacquiao. Oh... so you thought the fight was a mismatch in Oscar's favor, but Oscar himself saw it as a dangerous challenge. Don't buy it. Finally, he could have fought anybody and gotten criticism? Negative. Believe me when I tell you... and I'm as anti-Oscar as they come... I would've respected Oscar a lot more had he taken the fight that everyone in boxing wanted to see. Him against Margarito.

I would never have known..He fought the Bigger Hopkins, P4P King Floyd, Underfeated Tito, Shane, the list goes on, the man is not afraid of a challenge.

So true, Boom Boom. reps.

p.s. Dahlberg is a smart ass, always has been. He probably sits back and reads his own articles over and over and says to himself, "boy am I clever!".

can i add something... lots of money is involve and he is happy to take all that comes along his way...

[Taeth]

I remember Oscar making the feared Trinidad look like a fucking retard in the ring, at least he knows how to box properly... unlike Felix.

He's already taken on in his career Whitaker, JCC, Mosley, Camacho, Hopkins, MAyweather, Quartey, Vargas, Mayorga, Sturm, Gatti, Carr, Hernandez, Leija.

Who has a better resume against a higher quality of opposition, then you discredit him for not fighting Margarito because he is fighting Pacquiao in a no win situation? Do you know how many of these guys would beat Margarito?

[Mr140]

Tito just a hater on Oscar say what you want but Oscar has a great resume and lest no forget he did start 130 and went over to 160 and you talk about strum and gift decsion but Tito got a lesson by Oscar and he got a gift also so what comes around goes around he may of lost to Jones but lest not forget Jones was shot to bits anyhow so not that great lol.

[p4pking]

Well I think it's really more to do with money, but probably Oscar was concerned about going in against a number of Welterweights sure. Does that really make him worthy of your criticism though for christs sake? As Taeth said the guy has already fought a plethora of ridiculously talented fighters in his prime... Now that he is older the fact that he may have had a realistic Idea of what he can or can't do is supposed to make him a pussy or something? Why the hell would he bother to fight Margarito if he wasn't sure he'd win(which he most probably was positive he wouldn't)? Margarito isn't going to make him all that much money in future matchups the guy probably doesn't have long the way he fightts anyways. I mean just really try and think about what it might be like to be worth half a billion dollars from punching people in the face, basically. Why the hell would you want to fight anyone who could seriously hurt you much less in order to prove anything.

[TitoFan]

Tito just a hater on Oscar say what you want but Oscar has a great resume and lest no forget he did start 130 and went over to 160 and you talk about strum and gift decsion but Tito got a lesson by Oscar and he got a gift also so what comes around goes around he may of lost to Jones but lest not forget Jones was shot to bits anyhow so not that great lol.

Please don't count 160 among Oscar's weights. His adventure at 160 was even more ridiculous than Hatton's crack at 147. He got a gift against Sturm, and got KO'ed by a grazing liver shot by Hopkins. Tito, on the other hand, KO'ed a 160-pound champ in William Joppy, before getting beat by Hopkins. And whether Jones Jr. was shot or not, Tito went up 10 more pounds to 170 (admittedly not a smart move) to fight a naturally bigger man.

[TitoFan]

I remember Oscar making the feared Trinidad look like a fucking retard in the ring, (and yet he gets the decision in Oscar's backyard, Las Vegas, from 3 U.S. judges.... hmm... they must have seen something you didn't) at least he knows how to box properly... unlike Felix.

He's already taken on in his career Whitaker, JCC, Mosley, Camacho, Hopkins, MAyweather, Quartey, Vargas, Mayorga, Sturm, Gatti, Carr, Hernandez, Leija. (yes, and a lot them were either over-the-hill... ie: JCC... undersized... ie: Gatti... or damaged by Tito... ie: Vargas, Carr, Mayorga)

Who has a better resume against a higher quality of opposition, then you discredit him for not fighting Margarito because he is fighting Pacquiao in a no win situation? Do you know how many of these guys would beat Margarito?

You know, this could be a 100-year argument. But thankfully, neither you or I will last that long. You'll never convince me, and I'll never convince you.