Alright judah is getting way too many breaks here!!

[HattonTheHammer]

If it was the Zab Judah that threw fast combinations, used his jab, angles,and speedy footwork for 12 rounds I would pick Zab to beat him. But he throws less now and poses more, and he falls apart after 3 rounds against any elite fighter so I think Manny would probably edge him.

If however its the zab judah that turned up against baldomir and did absoloutely nothing for 12rounds other than pose it`ll be the biggest calamity of 2009.

This wont happen as theres just too much money in hatton-pacquiao for that NOT to happen!!

Id like to see judah in with berto to be honest

[Boom Boom]

I think it would be a joke anyways mostly because Judah does not deserve this fight, much like the Mayweather fight. I think he gets breaks though because people are interested in him. I admit I always watch him when he fights, I want to dislike him as a fighter but I dont.

As far as Judah-Berto, I think Berto would be to much for him and stop him.Bad matchup for Zab imo.

[HattonTheHammer]

I think it would be a joke anyways mostly because Judah does not deserve this fight, much like the Mayweather fight. I think he gets breaks though because people are interested in him. I admit I always watch him when he fights, I want to dislike him as a fighter but I dont.

As far as Judah-Berto, I think Berto would be to much for him and stop him.Bad matchup for Zab imo.

I dunno, kind of get the feeling bertos being held back a bit and kept away from the big boys which is a shame as he`s more than ready.

The only times ive actually ever really had respect for zab is in losing efforts against cotto & Mayweather when he actually seemed to give it his all and not the farcical fights he puts on with chop-chop and baldomir

[Spicoli]

Right now,at 140 which is the highest Pac should consider Imo....Perfect pickings for Pac.What is Zab going to keep him off with after initial 1 or 2 flashy shots.....The corner stool??I do not think Zab has it now to go through what it will take.

Also agree that Zab should have to earn his next high profile opportunity to lose

[C-Lo]

Zab has done nothing to earn a fight with Manny. If the fight is made, hopefully Zab gets brutally beaten and completely ends his career. Let's do it!

[Dizaster]

That's Zab.. He's always treated like a man one fight away from the title or the top of his weight class... I'm sure it's because of the potential he always shows in his losing fights.. He's better (well is probably better) than the the prospects and most of the contenders, so unless he goes backwards and fights prospects then what is he to do?
The general concensus I guess is that maybe he should pick bouts with 1 or 2 really decent contenders.. Win those fights, and have his shot at a champ.. He's just stuck at that A- level.. A tough place to be.. Ahead of the pack, but below the leaders...

Well, for his sake, as long as he keeps getting these big fights, he can earn $ and sleep well in his retirement if he's smart....

But Pac will destroy him, and there WILL come a point where he has to stop getting decent paying bouts... So he should make the most of them while he can, and make sure he manages what time he has left very well.

Maybe he needs a drastic change in training team.. If anyone still thinks he has the potential, then he needs a very good trainer to bring that out now before it's to late..


Finally, I think he may as well just try to make weight and stay at 140 and at least try to rule that division..

[Wadeb_21]

I'm in agreement with most people in this thread. What has judah done recently to warrant a Pac fight.... Nothing. I think he should fight Hatton or Bradley at 140 then if he wins Pac might be able to consider it.