So if Mayweather comes back and beats Pac and Margarito????

[Rantcatrat]

I don't see Paul Williams being a challenge at all, look at the first Quintana fight, Carlos is nowhere near Floyd's league, but being a counter puncher really caused Paul problems, he caught Carlos with a good punch in the second fight, but if that didn't happen we don't know how that fight would have turned out, but Paul might not even be able to make welterweight anymore.

IMO Pacquiao is the only fight left for Mayweather, they are of similar size, speed, skill(in different ways), conditioning, etc, etc. This would be a fight to definine Mayweather's career, I think he should only come back for fights that will be the most important fight of his career. Margarito wouldn't be, Paul Williams wouldn't be, Cotto wouldn't be, but Pacquiao would be, He's going to be considered the best fighter of the last 20 years by me until Floyd beats him. Nobody has done anything to compare with what Pacman has in the last 20 years, and that includes my two favorite fighters ever in Floyd and Roy.

Have you picked a winner in a Pacman v. PBF fight? From this post, I take it you think Pacman may win. If that is the case, I'll definitely lay a wager on it that PBF wins that fight.

I have heard the arguments as to why Pacman will win it, but I don't buy them.

[Rantcatrat]

I don't see Paul Williams being a challenge at all, look at the first Quintana fight, Carlos is nowhere near Floyd's league, but being a counter puncher really caused Paul problems, he caught Carlos with a good punch in the second fight, but if that didn't happen we don't know how that fight would have turned out, but Paul might not even be able to make welterweight anymore.

IMO Pacquiao is the only fight left for Mayweather, they are of similar size, speed, skill(in different ways), conditioning, etc, etc. This would be a fight to definine Mayweather's career, I think he should only come back for fights that will be the most important fight of his career. Margarito wouldn't be, Paul Williams wouldn't be, Cotto wouldn't be, but Pacquiao would be, He's going to be considered the best fighter of the last 20 years by me until Floyd beats him. Nobody has done anything to compare with what Pacman has in the last 20 years, and that includes my two favorite fighters ever in Floyd and Roy.

Paul Williams has improved quite a bit since that first fight with Quintana. Quintana gets all the credit for handing Williams his only loss, but Williams savagely avenged it. Since that loss, he beat Quintana, an average middleweight, and Phillips at junior middleweight to become a champion.

[Rantcatrat]

I don't see Paul Williams being a challenge at all, look at the first Quintana fight, Carlos is nowhere near Floyd's league, but being a counter puncher really caused Paul problems, he caught Carlos with a good punch in the second fight, but if that didn't happen we don't know how that fight would have turned out, but Paul might not even be able to make welterweight anymore.

IMO Pacquiao is the only fight left for Mayweather, they are of similar size, speed, skill(in different ways), conditioning, etc, etc. This would be a fight to definine Mayweather's career, I think he should only come back for fights that will be the most important fight of his career. Margarito wouldn't be, Paul Williams wouldn't be, Cotto wouldn't be, but Pacquiao would be, He's going to be considered the best fighter of the last 20 years by me until Floyd beats him. Nobody has done anything to compare with what Pacman has in the last 20 years, and that includes my two favorite fighters ever in Floyd and Roy.

Have you picked a winner in a Pacman v. PBF fight? From this post, I take it you think Pacman may win. If that is the case, I'll definitely lay a wager on it that PBF wins that fight.

I have heard the arguments as to why Pacman will win it, but I don't buy them.

Taeth - if the fight comes off, are we laying a wager down? I'll take PBF with whatever odds come with it.