Margarito vs Mosley: NOT for the Championship

[CFH]

A little slant on you title there Lance, you must be a politician or a salesman
Anyways, as much as I dislike the WBA, their belt is one of the major ones and Tony is the recognised champion by most observers. Is it just me or does the Ring rankings seem a little off in recent months?

To me it's since Golden Boy took over.

Then again I agree that this shouldn't be for the RING belt. To me Berto, Marg, and Williams if he decides to move back down should battle this out and now with Pac up there making waves and all the talk of a Mayweather comeback on the cards there is going to be a lot of competition for the REAL CHAMP.

Another factor is that Cotto could well come back in the New year and get a rematch with Marg and beat him. My point is I don't see the WW division clearing up any time soon but if I was to make my own top 5 and champ ranking it would be as follows:

Champ-Vacant
No.1- Williams (asuming he moves back down for a major fight)
No.2- Margarito
No.3- Berto
No.4- Cotto
No.5- Clottey

And then with Pac and Floyd most definitley breaking into it should Pac decide to stay there and Mayweather decide to comeback.

Out of curiosity, what's your reasoning for ranking Berto ahead of Cotto (and to a lesser extent Clottey)? I'm a fan of Berto's, but he's done nothing IMO to be ranked ahead of either Cotto or Clottey. I'm not sure I'd have him in the top 5 to be honest.

[rjj tszyu]

A little slant on you title there Lance, you must be a politician or a salesman
Anyways, as much as I dislike the WBA, their belt is one of the major ones and Tony is the recognised champion by most observers. Is it just me or does the Ring rankings seem a little off in recent months?

To me it's since Golden Boy took over.

Then again I agree that this shouldn't be for the RING belt. To me Berto, Marg, and Williams if he decides to move back down should battle this out and now with Pac up there making waves and all the talk of a Mayweather comeback on the cards there is going to be a lot of competition for the REAL CHAMP.

Another factor is that Cotto could well come back in the New year and get a rematch with Marg and beat him. My point is I don't see the WW division clearing up any time soon but if I was to make my own top 5 and champ ranking it would be as follows:

Champ-Vacant
No.1- Williams (asuming he moves back down for a major fight)
No.2- Margarito
No.3- Berto
No.4- Cotto
No.5- Clottey

And then with Pac and Floyd most definitley breaking into it should Pac decide to stay there and Mayweather decide to comeback.

Out of curiosity, what's your reasoning for ranking Berto ahead of Cotto (and to a lesser extent Clottey)? I'm a fan of Berto's, but he's done nothing IMO to be ranked ahead of either Cotto or Clottey. I'm not sure I'd have him in the top 5 to be honest.

Basically I have him ahead of Cotto on recent results. I love both guys but I can't help but think about Cotto on his knees after the Marg fight. And he's the unbeaten WBC champ which still does mean something IMO.

[Galaxy]

I can see both sides of the coin here.

But the fact remains it ain't for the championship!

Margarito was ranked 4th when he fought Cotto (#1 at the time of the fight) & although he had racked up wins he had still been beaten by Williams who was still at 147 (who says he still isn't? Although his last fight was at 154 IMO Williams/ Margarito 2 is the fight that needs to be made at 147) so win or lose Cotto/ Margarito was not for the championship either way!!!

The reason I feel it shouldn't qualify is that although Margarito defeated the #1 guy (Cotto) & is now fighting the current #3 guy who lost a close decision to the #1 Cotto at the time; should Mosley be victorious it would seem unfair to Cotto to recognise Mosley as champion because Cotto IMO is ranked higher than Mosley due to his win.

Either way with talk of Margarito/ Cotto 2 later next year the championship picture should become clearer.

Just because we feel someone should be champion doesn't mean they are & to follow that logic will only continue the chaos the alphabet idiots have created.

[hardcore_crash]

If you beat the #1 guy in the division, you are champion. Period.
Especially if you were the #4.

What about Marquez jumping to one fight at 135 and becoming the Ring Champion?

This is ridiculous hate on Margarito.

[Galaxy]

If you beat the #1 guy in the division, you are champion. Period.
Especially if you were the #4.

What about Marquez jumping to one fight at 135 and becoming the Ring Champion?

This is ridiculous hate on Margarito.

Wheres the hate?

Casamayor was champion & Marquez beat him!!!

Cotto was not champion & Williams had beaten Margarito so why would a Cotto/ Margarito fight be for the championship?

Its ridiculous to think Margarito would be rated ahead of Williams at the time!!!

And for the record if you beat the #1 guy your are not automatically champ, what about the guys ranked 2 & 3 especially if they hold a victory over you?

[Lance Uppercut]

If you beat the #1 guy in the division, you are champion. Period.
Especially if you were the #4.

What about Marquez jumping to one fight at 135 and becoming the Ring Champion?

This is ridiculous hate on Margarito.

Marquez did not fight the #1 contender; he fought THE champion. Anytime you beat the champ you become the champ.

The problem with Margarito is that he beat the #1 contender(Cotto) not the champ. Now Margarito is the the #1 contender. To become THE champ he has to solidify his position with a victory over the #2 contender, who happens to be Cotto due to Paul Williams departure to 154.

So we will likely have to wait until this summer before we have a welter-weight champion again.

The rules are simple and never change. Thus they ensure integrity; unlike the belts-for-sale method, as used by the various alphabet groups.

[hardcore_crash]

I was arguing completely out of line.
For some reason I was thinking Cotto had the ring belt

[GAME]

Thats why I think the ring belt is stupid. Casa. Was about a decade past his best . He should have lost to Cruz but they gave him the decision. Campbell was the unfied champ after beating Diaz for the belts.

All anyone had to do was beat Casa ( who should have lost to a bum on an undercard ) and they are the ring champ? Casa clearly wasnt the best in the world by the time he fought Marquez.

Not sure this fight should be for the ring title either . Paul Williams vs Tony 2 should be though