SO the debates you guys were having got me thinking, if everyone on here has their own way of coming up with a way to compile a P4P list, does each individual magazine or association have their own way too?

Does a p4p list in ring magazine have the same criteria as a list say on maxboxing or yahoo sports? If so wouldnt the lists be identical pretty much?

Another way you guys could try to settle this is by actually agreeing on the criteria for one list and then going from there. It makes more sense then one person having one list because he goes by how many amatuer bouts and how many girls that fighter slept with and another person having another list because he goes by how many ex-wifes the fighters have had.

Make sense?