How Did Miguel Cotto vs Antonio Margarito Win FOTY ?

[CGM]

It was a great championship fight that really meant something, in a very strong division. Between two admired and high profile fighters who fought their asses off. A good contrast in styles, a good clash of wills. I suppose there may have been "better" fights from a technical standpoint, but this one ruled because it had "the whole package", including some of the intangibles.

[Taeth]

Even if your going by popularity, how did Pacquiao-Marquez 2 no beat it? That fight was amazing, really close, there was knockdown, there was back and forth action. Watching both fights live, I found that fight way more intrigueing because it was close in every round, and they were trading huge punches.

In the Margarito-Cotto fight, Cotto was landing huge punches and Margarito was walking forwad, then it seemed like MArgarito was able to land for a round or two and it was over.

[Spicoli]

I went with Villa Vs. Mtagwa.No name recognition,no huge purses,title belts,or lucrative rematches waiting in the wings......just all out passion and honest action.Two guys who you probally will not see on a major network but just as worthy of the respect earned by all of the others mentioned.Just a fierce second to second brawl