I'd take Evander in a SD...it would be a barn burner...the real catch is it a 15 rounder or 12 rounder. I've always felt that the extra weight Holy put on to be a HW adversely affected his stamina and caused him to tire in the late rounds and only fight in spurts(especially post Bowe)...so if its 12 I take Evander if its 15 I lean towards Joe