This is a kinda silly thread IMO. If the definition of hype is noise about a fighter, then the definition of over-hype is when they don't live up to all the noise, therefore, I'd say that Zab Judah, James Toney and Jeff Lacy are all majorly over-hyped, Hattons bad night (were he still won) could be conceived as overhype, although I'm pretty sure he's gonna prove all the naysayers wrong, unlike Judah and Toney. Lacy needs to step it up before he goes off the radar.