Has anyone seen Setanta's top 10 p4p list?

[Fenster]

I don't get whats so ridiculous about Haye being P4P?

He'd spark all nine of those guys below him with a jab. Fact. Actually.. Hopkins and Calzaghe would probably need a right-hand to finish them. Fact.

[JazMerkin]

I don't get whats so ridiculous about Haye being P4P?

He'd spark all nine of those guys below him with a jab. Fact. Actually.. Hopkins and Calzaghe would probably need a right-hand to finish them. Fact.

In all honesty I would at least see Hopkins beating him because of ring-smarts, you have to remember the only time he's ever been down was when he was fighting at a stupidly high altitude, he just doesn't take the clean shots. I reckon Calzaghe could as well if could avoid getting pasted early on.

Hold on I just read Chris John's entry, WTF!!

[Fenster]

I don't get whats so ridiculous about Haye being P4P?

He'd spark all nine of those guys below him with a jab. Fact. Actually.. Hopkins and Calzaghe would probably need a right-hand to finish them. Fact.

In all honesty I would at least see Hopkins beating him because of ring-smarts, you have to remember the only time he's ever been down was when he was fighting at a stupidly high altitude, he just doesn't take the clean shots. I reckon Calzaghe could as well if could avoid getting pasted early on.

Hold on I just read Chris John's entry, WTF!!

Really? Hopkins ain't no Jones. Would his holding be effective against a naturally much bigger, stronger man?

So you reckon he could beat any current cruiserweight? Interesting.

[JazMerkin]

I don't get whats so ridiculous about Haye being P4P?

He'd spark all nine of those guys below him with a jab. Fact. Actually.. Hopkins and Calzaghe would probably need a right-hand to finish them. Fact.

In all honesty I would at least see Hopkins beating him because of ring-smarts, you have to remember the only time he's ever been down was when he was fighting at a stupidly high altitude, he just doesn't take the clean shots. I reckon Calzaghe could as well if could avoid getting pasted early on.

Hold on I just read Chris John's entry, WTF!!

Really? Hopkins ain't no Jones. Would his holding be effective against a naturally much bigger, stronger man?

So you reckon he could beat any current cruiserweight? Interesting.

I just think both Hopkins & Calzaghe would be too smart in the ring against a guy like Haye. Particularly with how wide Haye throws his punches. I couldn't see them knocking him out other than out of sheer exhaustion by Haye, but a definite points victory IMO

[Fenster]

In all honesty I would at least see Hopkins beating him because of ring-smarts, you have to remember the only time he's ever been down was when he was fighting at a stupidly high altitude, he just doesn't take the clean shots. I reckon Calzaghe could as well if could avoid getting pasted early on.

Hold on I just read Chris John's entry, WTF!!

Really? Hopkins ain't no Jones. Would his holding be effective against a naturally much bigger, stronger man?

So you reckon he could beat any current cruiserweight? Interesting.

I just think both Hopkins & Calzaghe would be too smart in the ring against a guy like Haye. Particularly with how wide Haye throws his punches. I couldn't see them knocking him out other than out of sheer exhaustion by Haye, but a definite points victory IMO

I can see both those guys beating SLOWER big men - but Haye has the speed. And anywhere he hits them will hurt.

I can't see Hopkins wanting to fight Haye, but he did want to face Maskaev a couple of years back.. so if the Klit fights fail to happen, I hope more people think like you. It would fascinating at the very least.

[kingfrnk]

Hopkins would beat Haye easy.