P4P is to imagine fighters in terms of their brilliance regardless of weight classes. If you look at the skill sets of the fighters that Mick lists and look at who they beat and at what point in their respective careers then it is my conclusion that Manny Pac would be out of his league with most of them. As an example, Tyson against Pac at some mythical comparable weight. I'm of the opinion that Manny gets decapitated.
Manny's big wins have all come against older fighters who have been in lots of wars. That's not his fault admittedly, but Pac doesn't have the P4P status that those other P4P no 1's have had. He's very good, of course he is. But he isn't a great like a Tyson or an Ali.
Bookmarks